Voting our Values
"Suppose that we didn't vote based on
economic self-interest, misplaced fears, or which candidate we'd rather have
a beer with. Instead, we cast our votes for candidates who shared our
deepest aspirations and ideals, and were pledged to respect those principles
as they went about the work of public policy.
"For instance, Americans overwhelmingly consider themselves to be what
people of faith call "stewards of creation." They recognize that we
have the power of life or death over Earth's other creatures, and with it an
awesome responsibility. If our electoral choices reflected this
belief, Congress would not be rushing headlong to make it easier to
eliminate endangered species.
"In Genesis, God announces his covenant, "which is between me and you
and every living creature of all flesh," not to destroy the world. How
dare we then destroy it ourselves, or grant the Secretary of the Interior
the power to decide which of Earth's creatures survive and which perish
"If we voted our values, talk about the
"sanctity of life" would not end at birth. Pesticides that can twist
the development of newborns would be banned. Our politicians wouldn't
let power companies dump toxic mercury into the air and, ultimately, into
our tuna salad sandwiches. Nor would they allow industrial emissions
that make it impossible for asthmatic children to play in the school yard.
"Americans also value personal
responsibility. "Clean up your mess," we teach our kids. Whether
its spilled milk on a kitchen table or toxic waste left behind at an
abandoned oil refinery, its the obligation of the person - or industry - who
made the mess to deal with it. That is the principle behind Superfund,
except that now our supposedly values-driven politicians are letting
industry off the hook, and putting the cleanup tab on your charge card
instead. What kind of morality is that?
"America is a materialistic culture, but
it's an ethical one, based on deeply entrenched notions of hard work and
fair play. But it's hardly fair that corporate "farmers" rake in huge
government subsidies, while real family farmers are forced off the land.
Politicians who upheld American values wouldn't let that happen.
"Nor would they tolerate the below-cost timber sales and sweetheart deals
for those seeking to exploit our national forests. Timber companies
don't pay market prices for the trees they log; in fact, in places like
Alaska's Tongrass National Forest, they expect us to pay for the roads, and
other costs of their operations. They don't pay for the fisheries they
destroy with the runoff from clearcuts. They don't even pay for the
cost of the forest fires fed by the huge slash piles and dried-out
ridgelines they leave behind. Instead, you and I finance the
destruction of our own natural resources, whether we like it or not.
"The constant companion to "work hard," in
the American value system, is "play by the rules." We don't pick and
choose which ones we want to follow: We have to stop at stop signs, even
when its 4 A.M. and there's no one else on the street. But favored
corporations get to pick and choose which rules to obey, because the EPA now
files only one-tenth as many lawsuits against major polluters as it did
under the Clinton administration.
"The most basic of environmental values is
prudence. "Better safe than sorry," we say. Yet our political
leaders continue to allow poorly understood chemical compounds to be dumped
into our water and air.
One result is that perchlorate, a rocket-fuel
ingredient, is now found in nearly every sample of milk and lettuce tested;
PBDE, a suspected neurotoxin in flame retardant, was detected in the breast
milk of women in Texas at rates 10 to 100 times those of European women.
Since the safety of these substances was not ascertained before they were
released into the environment, our politicians have chosen our sons and
daughters as de facto lab rats to test them.
"For all our purported division, Americans
do share a core set of values, including stewardship of the world and its
creatures, a belief that America's wild places are our common heritage,
respect for others, keeping promises, paying our way, prudence, humility,
and wonder at the intricate beauty of creation. We'd be happy to see
an election based on those values anytime."
- Carl Pope
Executive Director, Sierra Club
Reprinted with permission from Sierra magazine.
Photograph by Denis Nordmann (Switzerland).